Shortbread Thumbprints

Is there any better way to present a jam, than nestled in a delicious vanilla shortbread cookie? I think not. Which is why, when I found myself with several jars of jam on my hands, I immediately imagined dollops of the sugary goodness in thumbprint cookies.

The jam was left over from Christmas. I make my gifts, and last year I decided to make vanilla extract, vanilla scented salt, vanilla-pear jam, and blueberry-vanilla jam… Do you see a theme here? :-)… Anyway, turns out I made more jam than I needed, and 5 jars of the stuff would take me years to go through (if I were to use it on toast). Dave is particular and eats only red jams, so he is of no help.

Of course I don’t expect you to have vanilla jam on hand, nor do you need to. Use whatever jam is your favorite… However, if you’d like to try turning your preferred, store bought jam into a vanilla version, here’s how. Heat 1 cup of jam, 1/3 of a vanilla bean (split, scrape out caviar, and add both scrapings and pod to jam), and about 2 tablespoons of water (add more if needed). Heat over medium-low for 15 minutes (stirring frequently). Remove pod and transfer jam back to jar (if you used the whole jar) or into a new container, and let sit in refrigerator for a week to allow flavours to mingle… For homemade jam, I added the pods and the scrapings of 2 beans to a recipe that yielded a 6 cup batch.



Shortbread Thumbprints




Shortbread Thumbprints

1/2 cup Margarine

1/2 cup Shortening

2/3 cup Sugar

1 tbsp Non-Dairy Yogurt, plain or vanilla (I used coconut)

1 tsp Vanilla Extract

1/4 tsp Salt

2 cups All-Purpose Flour

1/2 cup Jam (your favorite)


Preheat oven to 350ยฐF.

Beat the margarine and shortening until thoroughly combined and smooth. Add the sugar and beat on medium for about 2 minutes. Add the yogurt, vanilla, and salt, beat for another 2 – 3 minutes. Add the flour and beat on low or stir in, until all the flour has been mixed in (careful not to over mix).

Using a level tablespoon to measure, scoop dough, roll into a ball, place about 2 inches apart on an ungreased cookies sheet, and gently press into 1/4 inch – 1/2 inch thick discs. Make an indentation in the center of discs and fill with jam.

Bake for 14 – 18 minutes, until the edges are lightly browned.

Allow to cool on sheet for 1 – 2 minutes before transferring to cooling rack. Cool completely.

Makes about 30 cookies.




16 thoughts on “Shortbread Thumbprints

    1. Starr

      I quite enjoyed the addition of vanilla to jam. The mild flavour of pear worked particularly well with it, and really allowed the vanilla to shine (plus you can see all the pretty vanilla flecks in it).

  1. Daisy

    These sound/look delicious!

    I was wondering do you have any ideas on what I could use to replace the yogurt?

    1. Starr

      Thank you ๐Ÿ™‚

      Without knowing your reason for the replacement, here are my suggestions (in order of preference)…

      Non-dairy sour cream
      Apple butter (unsweetened)
      Apple baby food (from jar, 1st stage)
      Applesauce (unsweetened)

      Please note, these are just suggestions. I have not tried any of them in this recipe.

  2. Barb@ThatWasVegan?

    I haven’t had thumbprint cookies in about a hundred years, I miss them! Love the sweetness of the jam with the crispy crunch of the cookie. SO GOOD! And these look beautiful!

  3. Pingback: Chocolate Shortbread Thumbprint Cookies | The Misfit Baker

Comments are closed.